PDA

View Full Version : PSU overkill?



Shedlife
17-01-09, 17:16
Why do people have such huggee PSU's?

E8400 @ 4GHZ
ASUS TRITON CPU COOLER
ASUS P5Q-PRO
OCZ 4GB 1000MHZ @ 10057
OCZ 900W MODXTREME PSU
BFG 9800GTX+ OC
SAMSUNG 1TB F1 HDD
SAMSUNG DVD-RW
ANTEC 900 CASE

I saw that in somebodies signature...surely that PC would be A-ok on 500W?

mac124
17-01-09, 17:28
Yeah a decent 500w psu would power that ok i would have thought. Thing is some people like to think ahead, say he upgraded to a 280gtx for example then the 500w psu would probably need replacing too which means the £50 spent on that would have been wasted.

alexnifty
17-01-09, 17:29
Maybe they are intending to go SLI at some point?

Lynx
17-01-09, 17:35
I have a 500w psu, which yes would do his system fine, but if i went to a bigger card, even to a 4870 i would be worried about consumption.

Shedlife
17-01-09, 20:36
Recommended psu of my gfx card (on the nvidia website), is 300W (minimum), I use 210W absoloutly fine. Soo, I think there is some miss leading going on XD

mac124
17-01-09, 20:43
Think its called covering ones backside ;) If they recommend a 200w psu and you have 6 hdd's or whatever and it didn't work on a 230w psu there maybe some unhappy customers out there.

Shedlife
17-01-09, 20:47
:chairfall::chairfall: yer ok, very true =]

b-star
19-01-09, 17:55
OCZ 900W MODXTREME PSU?

I wouldn't buy OCZ for sLI's, Crossfire's... or for high ed pc's which need GOOD/Powerful or with 700-1000W PSU

Be Quiet, Enermax, Corsair, Zalman...:thumbsup:

mac124
19-01-09, 18:24
If i were to buy a psu for a top end pc it would be seasonic, silverstone, pcp&c, bascally anything with a BIG SINGLE 12v rail.

alexnifty
19-01-09, 18:41
If i were to buy a psu for a top end pc it would be seasonic, silverstone, pcp&c, bascally anything with a BIG SINGLE 12v rail.

Concur +:thumbsup:

Aaron
19-01-09, 19:07
Also concur..

Shedlife
20-01-09, 20:22
how bigs big...mines 12amps xD I'm guessing sumit around 24amps?

Biodoid
20-01-09, 20:55
try 60 or 70amps :thumbsup:

mac124
20-01-09, 21:54
yeah around 60amp on the 12v rail for a 700ish watt psu is "big"

Aaron
20-01-09, 23:05
how bigs big...mines 12amps xD I'm guessing sumit around 24amps?
Mine has 70A on the 12v rail.. :)

mac124
21-01-09, 07:19
And its silverstone so gets the :thumbsup: from me ;).

Shedlife
21-01-09, 16:05
70A WOW :P thats BIG/overkill ^^ what cards would 9800's should work fine on 24A (thats what i've read anyway)

coiler
21-01-09, 16:08
70A WOW :P thats BIG/overkill ^^ what cards would 9800's should work fine on 24A (thats what i've read anyway)

not if gtx 260's are involved! :chairfall::chairfall::chairfall:

Audigex
21-01-09, 18:27
There's a link in the graphics card section showing how much certain graphics cards use at full load.
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/geforce-radeon-power,2122.html

From the rest of the data in that post, the system below draws at most 610 watts (with Dual GTX260's)

Now, that's a high draw CPU (65nm C2Extreme @ 3ghz)... running two GTX260s.

430watts whole system draw with a 4870 x2! FULL LOAD!
Going off that, I'd say a 600watt supply would be enough for just about any rig. Even if we allow for another two hard drives at 20W each (generous) and doubling the RAM, I cant' see actual draw being over 500W. Allowing another 100W for power fluctuations and I really think there's no need for a bigger supply. Maybe if you're running a heavily overclocked, watercooled 2x 4870X2 system with a stack of VelociRaptors in, you might need more. But I'd say 500W will be fine for most systems based on this.

CPU
Intel Core 2 Extreme X6800 @ 2.93 GHz (11x266 MHz), Socket 775, 1.28 V, 65 nm, 4096 KB L2 cacheFSB
1066 MHz (4x266 MHz)Motherboard
Asus P5E3 Deluxe, PCIe 2.0 2x16, ICH9R Chip Set
Intel X38Memory
2x1 GB, Ballistix (Crucial Technology) 1.5 V, DDR3 1066 7-7-7-20 (2x533 MHz)Audio
Intel High Definition AudioLAN
Intel 1000 Pro Hard Drive
Western Digital WD5000AAKS 500 GB, SATA, 16 MB cache
Hitachi 120 GB, SATA, 8 MB cache
DVD
Gigabyte GO-D1600C Power Supply
CoolerMaster RS-850-EMBA 850 W

Aaron
21-01-09, 19:21
And its silverstone so gets the :thumbsup: from me ;).

Anyone guess who I bought it from? :lol:

Biodoid
21-01-09, 22:25
wild shot in the dark here...but was it mac :lol:

Aaron
21-01-09, 22:26
:lol:

Unsurprisingly, yeah.. ;) :lol:

mac124
21-01-09, 22:28
Lol well i did seem to have an abundance of psu's at the time, iirc i had a 1kw Antec kicking around at the time too.

Aaron
21-01-09, 22:34
Well, it worked well all round.. :)

mac124
21-01-09, 22:34
Indeedy, :thumbsup: